Read The Forum Rules: We have a clear set of rules to keep the forum running smoothly. Click here to review them.

Post Reply 
The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
Author Message
redbeard Offline
Hummingbird
*****
Gold Member

Posts: 3,030
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation: 72
Post: #1
The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
We have a Catholic thread, but I figured a thread specific to the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) would be helpful.

Many forum members have found the TLM to be spectacular for understanding our faith and bringing us closer to Christ. I highly recommend everyone at least dip their toes in the Latin form. At the least, you'll be able to see what else is out there before committing to the Novus Ordo mass.

These videos from Dr. Taylor Marshall are a great introduction for beginners and veterans alike:






"Every saint has a past, every sinner a future."
(This post was last modified: 01-20-2020 10:12 AM by redbeard.)
01-20-2020 10:11 AM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 4 users Like redbeard's post:
NoMoreTO, Roosh, Emperor Constantine, Augustus_Principe
Roosh Offline
Eagle
*******

Posts: 19,874
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 420
Post: #2
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
I'm curious: have trad Catholics been learning Latin as a result? I would guess you only need to learn less than 500 words.

Roosh
http://www.rooshv.com
01-20-2020 01:22 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
Aurini Offline
Ostrich
****

Posts: 2,076
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 91
Post: #3
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-20-2020 01:22 PM)Roosh Wrote:  I'm curious: have trad Catholics been learning Latin as a result? I would guess you only need to learn less than 500 words.

Part of the reason that I appreciate Latin Mass is because I studied Latin in University; it's nice to have those skills reinforced with Pater Noster qui es in caelis...

It's the sort of thing - especially with children - that will help them adopt the language internally. And given that Latin is a grammatically superior language to any of the vulgar tongues, it will improve their cognition as adults, as well.

All of that said, there's a great deal of self righteousness in trad circles; spiritual pride. So the Church I go to, I go because the priest is a man I deeply respect, and the congregation is both humble and loving.

I do miss the organ music, though.

My website.
01-20-2020 01:45 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes Aurini's post:
Roosh
NoMoreTO Offline
Pelican
****

Posts: 1,180
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 16
Post: #4
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
4 ways to find Latin Mass Near You

(1) Diocese : Check with your local diocese website. Since Pope Benedict XVI, most Dioceses have a Latin Mass in one of their Churches to allow for the 'celebration of the extraordinary form'. In this case, you are going to a latin mass, at a Church that runs 'mostly' new masses. I spoke with a diocesan Priest who has been trained to celebrate latin mass, he explained that he can not really speak latin, but can pronounce it/read it, although he has to do some preparation before mass to make sure he has full understanding. I have attended Latin Masses at a Diocese in three separate locations. Estimated Female Veil Rate 1/3 although I have a special place in my heart for these girls raised in New Mass deciding to veil on their own!
PROS: Location may be very good for you, keeps a certain continuity with New Mass Catholics, Build the Latin Mass locally, Liturgy is exactly the same,
CONS: Parishioners are working still to learn the latin, when to get up and down, not all masses at the Church are latin. Sometimes you get a TLM once a month in a location. I have also found that the choir and such isn't quite as trained up as at a full latin apostolate. The Altar might still be out from the wall, although the orientation is 'ad orientum'.

(2) Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter (FSSP): Formed in 1988, they run parishes that run latin mass exclusively. There was essentially a split in 1988 from SSPX. I attend one of these Churches and it seems like the priests are formed very well. Thomas Aquinas is studied intensively in seminary, questions are asked in latin in their seminary. I have been attending an FSSP apostolate for about 6 months now. They 'Accept' Vatican 2, but don't seem to really preach it. Fr. Ripperberger was formed as an FSSP Priest. Estimated Female Veil Rate 2/3
PROS: Latin Mass Everyday, Classically Trained Priests, I found a very rounded out 'latin mass community' of very devout people who know the liturgy and have lots of traditions.
CONS: Order must be invited in by the Diocese, they do not have their own Bishop so priests must be ordained by local Bishop.
FSSP

(3) Society of St. Pius X (SSPX): "is an international priestly fraternity founded in 1970 by Marcel Lefebvre, the traditionalist French archbishop who later clashed with the Holy See over the Society. The Society, named after the anti-modernist Pope Pius X, is known for rejecting the indications of the Second Vatican Council". I have only gone to one SSPX Chapel, it seemed very devout. Female Veil Rate was 100%
PROS: They have their own Bishops, so they can operate independently of Holy See and Ordain their own Priests, Large Number of Chapels.
CONS: Can be a little rebellious to Rome, or could its a fine line.
SSPX

(4) The Institute of Christ the King: I have never been but have heard good things.
Institute of Christ the King

(5*) Sede Vacante Churches & Chapels running Latin Mass. These are not associated with Rome, so you would not be Roman Catholic but a form of Protestant who says the Pope is not sitting on the seat. The situation is difficult today with the Pope and Vatican 2, and no access to the Latin Mass Locally so there are Catholics who have chosen to worship in these places. I would advise Catholics to avoid.

For professing themselves to be wise, they became fools. Rom 1:22
(This post was last modified: 01-20-2020 02:51 PM by NoMoreTO.)
01-20-2020 02:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 7 users Like NoMoreTO's post:
911, redbeard, DJ-Matt, Renzy, Emperor Constantine, RoastBeefCurtains4Me, Augustus_Principe
RexImperator Offline
Crow
*****
Gold Member

Posts: 5,652
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 27
Post: #5
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
Quote: I'm curious: have trad Catholics been learning Latin as a result? I would guess you only need to learn less than 500 words.

Usually there’s an English translation in the booklet next to the Latin words of the service, so it’s pretty easy to follow and pick things up as you go. Latin forming the basis of many European languages helps make it less alien than one might think.

Bella, horrida bella
et Thybrim multo spumantem sanguine cerno
01-20-2020 03:49 PM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes RexImperator's post:
Emperor Constantine
Roosh Offline
Eagle
*******

Posts: 19,874
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 420
Post: #6
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-20-2020 03:49 PM)RexImperator Wrote:  
Quote: I'm curious: have trad Catholics been learning Latin as a result? I would guess you only need to learn less than 500 words.

Usually there’s an English translation in the booklet next to the Latin words of the service, so it’s pretty easy to follow and pick things up as you go. Latin forming the basis of many European languages helps make it less alien than one might think.

That's the same for the Armenian liturgy in that there's a service book, but I feel a pull to learn Classical Armenian (which can be very different from modern Armenian). My priest said I really have to learn only 300 words. I imagine you'd feel closer to God staring at the altar than at a service book.

Roosh
http://www.rooshv.com
01-20-2020 04:06 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 3 users Like Roosh's post:
Enigma, NoMoreTO, Augustus_Principe
911 Offline
Crow
*****

Posts: 5,998
Joined: Mar 2016
Reputation: 60
Post: #7
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-20-2020 01:22 PM)Roosh Wrote:  I'm curious: have trad Catholics been learning Latin as a result? I would guess you only need to learn less than 500 words.

If you speak Italian, French or Spanish, basic Latin is easy enough to learn. It's closest to Italian.

Latin used to be an integral part of the middle school curriculum in France, at least as an option. It's being weeded out in the public school system for political/anticlerical reasons, but still taught in parochial schools along with classical Greek (mostly Catholic schools, we threw our Protestants out a while back, I don't think Protestants are into Latin).

λ ό γ ο ς
01-20-2020 04:40 PM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 3 users Like 911's post:
NoMoreTO, Aurini, Augustus_Principe
NoMoreTO Offline
Pelican
****

Posts: 1,180
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 16
Post: #8
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
Learning Latin I think is a lot easier than some of the eastern languages (eg. Greek, Armenian)
- we have latin all over English words
- same Roman alphabet
- pronunciation is pretty easy, most words are pretty phonetic
- there is latin in Duolingo

There is actually ecclesiastical latin (aka Church latin) and latin from the Roman era, some of the pronunciations are slightly different but I think the structure and words are pretty similar.

Here are some basic prayers in Latin in Audio from Dr. Taylor Marshall (Guy in OPs' post). These are free documents, that were sent to me so I think its ok to redistribute. I would actually recommend his institute.

Our Father (Pater Noster)
Hail Mary (Ave Maria)
Glory Be (Gloria)
Table Blessing

Latin Prayers Audio Sample_DrTM_2minutes

Link to Rosary Prayer Text & pronunciation rules - Latin

For professing themselves to be wise, they became fools. Rom 1:22
(This post was last modified: 01-20-2020 06:18 PM by NoMoreTO.)
01-20-2020 06:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 3 users Like NoMoreTO's post:
Roosh, redbeard, Renzy
Rob Banks Online
Kingfisher
***

Posts: 719
Joined: Oct 2016
Reputation: 12
Post: #9
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-20-2020 02:37 PM)NoMoreTO Wrote:  (5*) Sede Vacante Churches & Chapels running Latin Mass. These are not associated with Rome, so you would not be Roman Catholic but a form of Protestant who says the Pope is not sitting on the seat. The situation is difficult today with the Pope and Vatican 2, and no access to the Latin Mass Locally so there are Catholics who have chosen to worship in these places. I would advise Catholics to avoid.

I started going to a Traditional Latin Mass (SSPX) church last week. It was recommended to me by a forum member on another thread.

However, I have been watching/reading sedevacantist videos and websites, and their opinion seems to be that the SSPX position of "recognize & resist" (i.e. recognize the post-Vatican II popes but resist their heretical teachings) is wrong. One sedevacantist priest was even saying that he is theologically closer to Novus Ordo churches than SSPX churches because both he and the Novus Ordo churches recognize the fact that Catholics must submit to the pope (when there is one), whereas SSPX believes that it is OK for Catholics to recognize the pope but not submit to his authority.

I was wondering what do traditional Catholics think about this?
01-20-2020 06:13 PM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
redbeard Offline
Hummingbird
*****
Gold Member

Posts: 3,030
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation: 72
Post: #10
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
I'm slowly picking up Latin in the process. I'm not a fast learner when it comes to languages and I haven't been as diligent about extra-curricular study. But, Latin is similar enough that it's not too difficult.

On top of that, I agree with the others that you don't need to be fluent to understand the mass. There's only so many words in the liturgy.

This is doubly true if you have a background of going to N.O. mass, since you see the basic framework of the mass. You don't have to know what every word means to understand what is being said.

"Every saint has a past, every sinner a future."
01-21-2020 08:46 AM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
redbeard Offline
Hummingbird
*****
Gold Member

Posts: 3,030
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation: 72
Post: #11
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
The SSPX issue is tricky and I wish both sides (Vatican & SSPX) were a bit more clear about what's going on. Everyone loves to bring up the "fact" that "SSPX is excommunicated," but where's the citation? Why are they so afraid of the society?

NoMoreTO and I talked about this a bit earlier:

(12-17-2019 09:13 AM)NoMoreTO Wrote:  
(12-17-2019 07:27 AM)redbeard Wrote:  
(12-16-2019 10:03 PM)NoMoreTO Wrote:  
(12-16-2019 08:11 AM)redbeard Wrote:  Great read on St. Marys. Inspiring.

However, I have an issue with SSPX's relationship with the Vatican. I haven't done enough research and I'm not completely convinced on all the sedevacantism stuff.

SSPX is not Sedevacantist. Still, I can understand your reticence given the fact that their bishops were excommunicated and now brought back into the fold.

I must've heard wrong. Is there any site that explains this situation well? I was under the impression SSPX sacraments were not acceptable under the Church.

I could be wrong but, as far as I understand:
1. Baptism is legitimate whenever it is done properly
2. Eucharist is based on the priest receiving his holy orders via valid bishop (which SSPX have) to consecrate host
3. Confession is the 'Keys' that loose and bind, and comes through the Church Authority. So yes, this was in question. It seems like Pope Francis has lifted this
Quote:In order for a priest to validly witness marriages and grant absolution in confession, a priest requires not only the sacrament of Holy Orders but also the faculties — or permission — of a bishop in union with the Pope. Although Pope Francis has extended faculties to absolve sins, he has not granted similar faculties for SSPX clergy to validly witness marriages.

SSPX Confession
4. Marriage : According to the article SSPX does not yet have marriage authority. Something similar happened to a priest of mine where he had to find a friendly Bishop to allow him to marry people in another district
5. Holy Orders The priests are legitimate through apostolic succession. SSPX has its own Bishops and can consecrate its priests independently.
6. Extreme Unction - Not sure
7. Confirmation - Not sure

However I think that article is outdated. An interesting development is that in 2017 the Vatican allowed SSPX to ordain marriages and the sacrament of penance. If the society was so heretical, why would Pope Francis explicitly recognize their right to ordain sacraments?

"Every saint has a past, every sinner a future."
01-21-2020 09:00 AM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes redbeard's post:
fr0st
NoMoreTO Offline
Pelican
****

Posts: 1,180
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 16
Post: #12
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-20-2020 06:13 PM)Rob Banks Wrote:  
(01-20-2020 02:37 PM)NoMoreTO Wrote:  (5*) Sede Vacante Churches & Chapels running Latin Mass. These are not associated with Rome, so you would not be Roman Catholic but a form of Protestant who says the Pope is not sitting on the seat. The situation is difficult today with the Pope and Vatican 2, and no access to the Latin Mass Locally so there are Catholics who have chosen to worship in these places. I would advise Catholics to avoid.

I started going to a Traditional Latin Mass (SSPX) church last week. It was recommended to me by a forum member on another thread.

However, I have been watching/reading sedevacantist videos and websites, and their opinion seems to be that the SSPX position of "recognize & resist" (i.e. recognize the post-Vatican II popes but resist their heretical teachings) is wrong. One sedevacantist priest was even saying that he is theologically closer to Novus Ordo churches than SSPX churches because both he and the Novus Ordo churches recognize the fact that Catholics must submit to the pope (when there is one), whereas SSPX believes that it is OK for Catholics to recognize the pope but not submit to his authority.

I was wondering what do traditional Catholics think about this?

Catholics must submit to Authority unless they order us to do something that goes against God. This applies to the Pope, but also your boss at work, and if you are a woman, your husband.

The Word Catholic means Universal. We believe in a Visible Church and a Pope. This is why 'some' Sede Vacantists have even elected their own Pope, and technically they have some backing.

SSPX, FSSP are supporting the tradition, there is nothing in Catholic Dogma about having a New Mass. In fact, the Catechism of Trent asserts the Tridentine Mass (TLM) as the Mass of All Ages. The mass is a proper prayer and a sacrifice, and will always be legitimate.

SSPX has not formally declared in anyway Vatican 2 heresy, as I understand it they have 'questions'. Which the Church should indeed be answering, that is what the Church is supposed to do. Lefebvre did break with Authority when he consecrated his own Bishops without the Popes authority. This is automatic ex communication, the Pope didn't even need to say anything. Remember , that Lefebvre himself signed Vatican 2.

For professing themselves to be wise, they became fools. Rom 1:22
01-21-2020 10:00 AM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 2 users Like NoMoreTO's post:
redbeard, Augustus_Principe
NoMoreTO Offline
Pelican
****

Posts: 1,180
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 16
Post: #13
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
Blog Article on TLM from a Priest.

A diocese smells the coffee: starts planning for decline of the Novus Ordo and growth of the TLM

Quote:A demographic sink hole is about to open up under the Church in these USA and elsewhere. Younger people are in large part “nones”, that is, professing no religion.
...
A friend of mine used to say provocatively that one day the Novus Ordo would disappear and only the TLM would remain. I didn’t buy that at the time. These days, I’m not so sure.
...
Frankly, as I have written before, I think that when the sink hole opens two groups will remain strong and vibrant: evangelical converts and charismatics and, on the other hand, traditionalists. Eventually these two groups will move closer and closer together and start to cross pollinate. As a matter of fact, I think that it is already happening.
Fr. John Zuhlsdorf

For professing themselves to be wise, they became fools. Rom 1:22
01-21-2020 10:15 AM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 2 users Like NoMoreTO's post:
redbeard, Renzy
redbeard Offline
Hummingbird
*****
Gold Member

Posts: 3,030
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation: 72
Post: #14
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
It's also worth noting that the SSPX bishops excommunicated by the Econe consecrations were reversed in 2009:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89c%C3...unications

"Every saint has a past, every sinner a future."
01-21-2020 10:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes redbeard's post:
NoMoreTO
Handsome Creepy Eel Online
Owl
******
Gold Member

Posts: 12,671
Joined: Apr 2011
Reputation: 169
Post: #15
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
Other than in the Vatican itself, I don't see the appeal of a Mass in Latin. My ancestors fought hard for the right to conduct the mass in their native languages over 1000 years ago so that all of their people would be able to understand the Word. Why abandon that?

"Imagine" by HCE | Hitler reacts to Battle of Montreal | An alternative use for squid that has never crossed your mind before
(This post was last modified: 01-21-2020 12:00 PM by Handsome Creepy Eel.)
01-21-2020 11:50 AM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes Handsome Creepy Eel's post:
roberto
NoMoreTO Offline
Pelican
****

Posts: 1,180
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 16
Post: #16
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-21-2020 11:50 AM)Handsome Creepy Eel Wrote:  Other than in the Vatican itself, I don't see the appeal of a Mass in Latin. My ancestors fought hard for the right to conduct the mass in their native languages over 1000 years ago so that all of their people would be able to understand the Word. Why abandon that?

- Who are your ancestors and why did they revolt?

- Latin is a holy language, it is the language of the Church of Rome. If you are part of this Church, than latin is the language. There are places where everyone speaks different languages (imagine Africa) and we are all united in Latin. Half the people in my Church speak French, but we can pray together.

- Latin is a holy language, there were 3 languages on the cross, one was latin. The other 2 were greek, Aramaic.

- Latin is a dead language, this means the meanings of the words are fixed and there is no room for manipulation.

- The latin mass liturgy actually is more than just the language. It is the form of the entire mass. When the language of the mass was changed in the late 60s (Coincidence?), they didn't just change the language to the local vernacular, they changed the entire mass. So Latin Mass is slang for 'Old Mass'.

- Personally, I would go to a Mass in English which was a Tridentine mass over a New Mass said in Latin. It represents customs.

For professing themselves to be wise, they became fools. Rom 1:22
(This post was last modified: 01-21-2020 01:21 PM by NoMoreTO.)
01-21-2020 01:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 5 users Like NoMoreTO's post:
redbeard, Renzy, robreke, Augustus_Principe, WillOfTheD
Rob Banks Online
Kingfisher
***

Posts: 719
Joined: Oct 2016
Reputation: 12
Post: #17
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-21-2020 11:50 AM)Handsome Creepy Eel Wrote:  Other than in the Vatican itself, I don't see the appeal of a Mass in Latin. My ancestors fought hard for the right to conduct the mass in their native languages over 1000 years ago so that all of their people would be able to understand the Word. Why abandon that?

Because the new Mass was introduced during Vatican II and therefore represents all the other changes that Vatican II brought to the church.

If they had only changed the Mass from Latin to English and nothing else, it wouldn't be as big of a deal. But that's not what they did. They changed the Mass and they also started to promote all sorts of other teachings that a lot of traditional Catholics consider to be heresies, such as teaching that salvation can be attained through all religions, or teaching that procreation is not the primary objective of sex and marriage (among many others)
01-21-2020 03:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes Rob Banks's post:
Handsome Creepy Eel
kel Offline
Kingfisher
***

Posts: 565
Joined: Dec 2019
Reputation: 2
Post: #18
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-21-2020 11:50 AM)Handsome Creepy Eel Wrote:  Other than in the Vatican itself, I don't see the appeal of a Mass in Latin. My ancestors fought hard for the right to conduct the mass in their native languages over 1000 years ago so that all of their people would be able to understand the Word. Why abandon that?

Also, let's break mass into the liturgy and preaching. The liturgy is ritual, it's meditative and transcendent. You're supposed to feel ancientness and infinity in it. You can learn the Latin needed for this ritual in, literally, a matter of minutes. You can know exactly what is being said and what it means and enjoy it in the language it was written in. Then there's the preaching, which should be done in the vernacular so everyone can understand and discuss.
01-21-2020 03:41 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes kel's post:
WillOfTheD
Emperor Constantine Offline
Robin
*

Posts: 176
Joined: May 2019
Reputation: 2
Post: #19
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-21-2020 03:41 PM)kel Wrote:  The liturgy is ritual, it's meditative and transcendent. You're supposed to feel ancientness and infinity in it. You can learn the Latin needed for this ritual in, literally, a matter of minutes. You can know exactly what is being said and what it means and enjoy it in the language it was written in.

You were able to learn in a matter of minutes all the Latin you needed to understand the Tridentine Mass?

I am impressed. I took Latin all through middle and high school, read Vulgate and parts of Ceasar's memoirs, and still could not keep up the first time I went to the Latin Mass in 10th or 11th grade. No doubt it would have gotten easier with practice.

I think it's crucial to understand and internalize the liturgy, since there is so much theology written into it. But the missal always has English on one side of the page, so a lack of Latin fluency shouldn't be a huge obstacle for most people who choose to attend the Latin liturgy.
01-21-2020 11:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes Emperor Constantine's post:
NoMoreTO
Handsome Creepy Eel Online
Owl
******
Gold Member

Posts: 12,671
Joined: Apr 2011
Reputation: 169
Post: #20
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-21-2020 01:20 PM)NoMoreTO Wrote:  - Who are your ancestors and why did they revolt?

[Image: estatua-de-grgur-ninski.jpg]

My hometown has a giant statue of this Croatian Bishop called Grgur Ninski (Gregory of Nin) who got the permission from Rome to celebrate the Mass in the local language instead of Latin in 926. He was later replaced and had his Bishopric dissolved after infighting within the church, but the tradition remained and our language and alphabet thrived thanks to this, and we remained in the Roman sphere of influence rather than the Byzantine.

Quote:- Latin is a holy language, it is the language of the Church of Rome. If you are part of this Church, than latin is the language. There are places where everyone speaks different languages (imagine Africa) and we are all united in Latin. Half the people in my Church speak French, but we can pray together.

First of all, no language is holy. A language is merely a communication device that's influenced by all sorts of wordly factors starting from the Tower of Babel onwards. Jesus did not speak Latin, and the early Church did not celebrate the Mass in Latin either. So should we all learn and use Greek or Aramaic or whatever other language represented at that time? Of course not. A language is not holy, nor can it make anything holy. It is just a tool like a sheet of paper or a pipe organ .

Quote:Latin is a dead language, this means the meanings of the words are fixed and there is no room for manipulation.

I don't see how this matters at all, as words can always be translated differently. Furthermore, it is our task as Christians to guard our language against such manipulation, not to flock to a language to supposedly protect us from it.

Quote:The latin mass liturgy actually is more than just the language. It is the form of the entire mass. When the language of the mass was changed in the late 60s (Coincidence?), they didn't just change the language to the local vernacular, they changed the entire mass. So Latin Mass is slang for 'Old Mass'.

It seems to me that you're confusing and conflating Tridentine Mass with Latin. It's up to you to believe whether Novus Ordo is unsuitable or not, but the issue has nothing to do with Latin. People used to celebrate the old mass in numerous languages throughout history. I just gave you an example from my country that's over 1000 years old.

kel Wrote:Also, let's break mass into the liturgy and preaching. The liturgy is ritual, it's meditative and transcendent. You're supposed to feel ancientness and infinity in it. You can learn the Latin needed for this ritual in, literally, a matter of minutes. You can know exactly what is being said and what it means and enjoy it in the language it was written in.

The problem with this way of thinking is that it turns the Mass from earnest prayer into a bureaucratic formality, as if it were an ancient Druidic Ritual or a Lvl 9 Transmutation spell out of D&D.

At best, it becomes en empty repetition based on "Perform action A, get the result B" like in Islam where everyone learns Arabic for some insane ethnicity-based reason.

At worst, it leads to ridiculous Pharisee-type thinking of "We're all praying, but see, I'm the only one doing it correctly!"

Moral of the story is, the Order of the Mass might have something to do with holiness, but the language doesn't.

"Imagine" by HCE | Hitler reacts to Battle of Montreal | An alternative use for squid that has never crossed your mind before
(This post was last modified: 01-22-2020 06:02 AM by Handsome Creepy Eel.)
01-22-2020 06:02 AM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 2 users Like Handsome Creepy Eel's post:
Emperor Constantine, HermeticAlly
Emperor Constantine Offline
Robin
*

Posts: 176
Joined: May 2019
Reputation: 2
Post: #21
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-22-2020 06:02 AM)Handsome Creepy Eel Wrote:  So should we all learn and use Greek or Aramaic or whatever other language represented at that time? Of course not.

(01-22-2020 06:02 AM)Handsome Creepy Eel Wrote:  ... like in Islam where everyone learns Arabic for some insane ethnicity-based reason.

I've heard from the one Muslim I know that they learn Arabic so they can read the Koran in its original tongue. Nothing is ever quite the same when translated, even though if translated properly (which is far from guaranteed with Bibles these days) it will give largely the same meaning.

That's why it's pretty typical for seminary students to learn a bit of koine Greek; so that they can gain a better understanding of the New Testament by reading it in the tongue it was written in. I don't think it's at all necessary to learn New Testament Greek to be a Christian, but it's very worthwhile.
01-22-2020 08:57 AM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes Emperor Constantine's post:
Handsome Creepy Eel
NoMoreTO Offline
Pelican
****

Posts: 1,180
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 16
Post: #22
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-22-2020 06:02 AM)Handsome Creepy Eel Wrote:  
(01-21-2020 01:20 PM)NoMoreTO Wrote:  - Who are your ancestors and why did they revolt?

First of all, no language is holy. A language is merely a communication device that's influenced by all sorts of wordly factors starting from the Tower of Babel onwards. Jesus did not speak Latin, and the early Church did not celebrate the Mass in Latin either. So should we all learn and use Greek or Aramaic or whatever other language represented at that time? Of course not. A language is not holy, nor can it make anything holy. It is just a tool like a sheet of paper or a pipe organ .

Quote:Latin is a dead language, this means the meanings of the words are fixed and there is no room for manipulation.

I don't see how this matters at all, as words can always be translated differently. Furthermore, it is our task as Christians to guard our language against such manipulation, not to flock to a language to supposedly protect us from it.

Quote:The latin mass liturgy actually is more than just the language. It is the form of the entire mass. When the language of the mass was changed in the late 60s (Coincidence?), they didn't just change the language to the local vernacular, they changed the entire mass. So Latin Mass is slang for 'Old Mass'.

It seems to me that you're confusing and conflating Tridentine Mass with Latin. It's up to you to believe whether Novus Ordo is unsuitable or not, but the issue has nothing to do with Latin. People used to celebrate the old mass in numerous languages throughout history. I just gave you an example from my country that's over 1000 years old.

kel Wrote:Also, let's break mass into the liturgy and preaching. The liturgy is ritual, it's meditative and transcendent. You're supposed to feel ancientness and infinity in it. You can learn the Latin needed for this ritual in, literally, a matter of minutes. You can know exactly what is being said and what it means and enjoy it in the language it was written in.

The problem with this way of thinking is that it turns the Mass from earnest prayer into a bureaucratic formality, as if it were an ancient Druidic Ritual or a Lvl 9 Transmutation spell out of D&D.

At best, it becomes en empty repetition based on "Perform action A, get the result B" like in Islam where everyone learns Arabic for some insane ethnicity-based reason.

At worst, it leads to ridiculous Pharisee-type thinking of "We're all praying, but see, I'm the only one doing it correctly!"

Moral of the story is, the Order of the Mass might have something to do with holiness, but the language doesn't.

Latin if it is not a holy Language, is a language related to all things Roman Catholic, which existed in the time of the New Testament, and seems to have an increased spiritual power. As support, exorcists such as Fr. Ripperberger have said that Latin works better in excorcising demons. There is no corruption in the words vs. the tradition. For example, if you pray a Pater Noster, this is the language used for centuries past. It is also the official language of the Church of Rome, all official Church documents are written in Latin. I can understand that a language is just a language, but the fact that latin is used exclusively to read Church documents, along with use in Legal world is something to consider. Also, Pipe Organs were made specifically to assist the Gregorian Chant, so they are holy in that their design was intrinsically spiritually focussed.

There is no confusion about structure of a mass vs. it being in Latin. There are very few Latin Masses which are not Tridentine, this is the first that I heard of this Croatian exception. So the two are used interchangeably. In most circles the two are used interchangeably.

Could you have a Tridentine Mass that was not in Latin? I am actually not sure. You could say all the exact same prayers in a native tongue, but it might not qualify as Tridentine. Remember in Tridentine, every Rubric is Fixed, this includes language. As I understand it, this is basically what people THOUGHT they would be getting after Vatican 2, along with some slight adjustments.

Your point on the pharisee holier than thou mentality is well taken, we should always guard against this. But be careful not to walk the Prot path too hard. As much as Trads can be Latin Snobs, at the same time we must always offer our BEST to God in the Mass. For me, it seems Latin is best, and taking some effort to learn and study latin for God's sake is admirable.

Bottom Line: this is the ROMAN RITE, so if Latin bugs you so much, consider searching yourself for Prot influences. Rebellion against the Church is not Catholic. Obedience is.

For professing themselves to be wise, they became fools. Rom 1:22
(This post was last modified: 01-22-2020 03:33 PM by NoMoreTO.)
01-22-2020 02:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 5 users Like NoMoreTO's post:
Emperor Constantine, redbeard, Handsome Creepy Eel, Sankt Michael, Augustus_Principe
Emperor Constantine Offline
Robin
*

Posts: 176
Joined: May 2019
Reputation: 2
Post: #23
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-22-2020 02:45 PM)NoMoreTO Wrote:  As support, exorcists such as Fr. Ripperberger have said that Latin works better in excorcising demons.

Is the exorcism rite the same in Latin and in the vernacular, or did that get Paul VId along with everything else? My sister recently recounted a story to me: a seminary director gave his students holy water blessed under the old rite, and they all started telling him that the latest batch of holy water suddenly seemed more powerful. He went through the prayers of blessing and realized that the Novus Ordo version was really watered down (heh) from the old Latin version.

Interstingly, some Russian Orthodox clergy claim Church Slavonic is more spiritually potent than modern Russian.

On a related note, this website has very good audio of the psalms in Latin for anyone interested in praying them in this manner: https://www.virgosacrata.com/parallel-la...sh-psalter
01-22-2020 11:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes Emperor Constantine's post:
NoMoreTO
NoMoreTO Offline
Pelican
****

Posts: 1,180
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 16
Post: #24
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-22-2020 11:21 PM)Emperor Constantine Wrote:  
(01-22-2020 02:45 PM)NoMoreTO Wrote:  As support, exorcists such as Fr. Ripperberger have said that Latin works better in excorcising demons.

Is the exorcism rite the same in Latin and in the vernacular, or did that get Paul VId along with everything else? My sister recently recounted a story to me: a seminary director gave his students holy water blessed under the old rite, and they all started telling him that the latest batch of holy water suddenly seemed more powerful. He went through the prayers of blessing and realized that the Novus Ordo version was really watered down (heh) from the old Latin version.

Interstingly, some Russian Orthodox clergy claim Church Slavonic is more spiritually potent than modern Russian.

On a related note, this website has very good audio of the psalms in Latin for anyone interested in praying them in this manner: https://www.virgosacrata.com/parallel-la...sh-psalter

The Priest at my Church has confirmed the same thing.

The holy water at our Church is exorcised with Salt. The ritual is longer and more exorcisms are done to the water prior to blessing it. The FSSP Mindset seems to be "The Devil is Real and we are at war with him". So there is a real push to first expel him in so many ways.

The holy water at a Novus Ordo is holy in that it is blessed, but it seems they don't do a full exorcism ritual beforehand. The mentality at Novus Ordo seems to be less fearful of the devil and more "We believe in the Devil but we focus on the water being blessed by God". Rather than add additional blessings, the New Rite seems to pull out and shorten the exorcism. (As I understand it)

Similar with baptism, the old rite has extensive exorcisms before baptizing the person. You can imagine how many demons there were in ancient Rome.

For professing themselves to be wise, they became fools. Rom 1:22
01-23-2020 10:00 AM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes NoMoreTO's post:
Emperor Constantine
Captainstabbin Online
Hummingbird
*****

Posts: 3,623
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 23
Post: #25
RE: The Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Thread
(01-21-2020 11:50 AM)Handsome Creepy Eel Wrote:  Other than in the Vatican itself, I don't see the appeal of a Mass in Latin. My ancestors fought hard for the right to conduct the mass in their native languages over 1000 years ago so that all of their people would be able to understand the Word. Why abandon that?

A. The value of Latin is that, as a dead language, the meaning of words doesn't continue to change.

B. The Latin Mass was exactly what you're describing. It was a translation of Greek and Aramaic (and a few others) to the local vernacular. Rome spoke Latin, so translating the mass to Latin was done so local people could understand it. There's nothing holy about the language itself. There's nothing that makes the mass more effective if it's in Latin. Jesus didn't say the first mass in Latin, the early apostles didn't either.

The only real problem is that, when the mass is translated to other languages, the translators substantively (and purposely) change the meaning. The NO mass is, officially, in Latin. Doesn't make it valid.
01-24-2020 03:36 AM
Find all posts by this user Like Post Quote this message in a reply
[-] The following 1 user Likes Captainstabbin's post:
NoMoreTO
Post Reply 


Forum Jump:


User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)

Contact Us | RooshV.com | Return to Top | Return to Content | Mobile Version | RSS Syndication